1
00:00:00,169 --> 00:00:03,605
In the criminal justice system,
the people are represented
2
00:00:03,673 --> 00:00:06,206
by two separate yet
equally important groups:
3
00:00:06,274 --> 00:00:08,242
The police who
investigate crime
4
00:00:08,309 --> 00:00:11,412
and the crown prosecutors
who prosecute the offenders.
5
00:00:11,480 --> 00:00:13,313
These are their stories.
6
00:00:15,950 --> 00:00:18,486
( Music blares from upstairs )
7
00:00:24,859 --> 00:00:26,058
Leila?
8
00:00:28,796 --> 00:00:31,030
Leila!
9
00:00:31,098 --> 00:00:33,232
( Music stops )
10
00:00:33,300 --> 00:00:35,502
Leila!
11
00:00:35,569 --> 00:00:39,204
Do you think Alex can sleep
with that racket on?
12
00:00:39,272 --> 00:00:41,306
Sorry, I wasn't thinking.
Yeah.
13
00:00:41,374 --> 00:00:44,276
Hope you had the monitor with you.
Of course.
14
00:00:44,343 --> 00:00:45,844
He's out for the count.
15
00:00:49,449 --> 00:00:51,983
The monitor is switched off, leila.
16
00:00:52,051 --> 00:00:53,451
( Continuous beeping )
17
00:00:55,487 --> 00:00:57,789
Call 999.
18
00:00:57,856 --> 00:01:00,425
( Beeping continues
) Phone 999, leila.
19
00:01:02,160 --> 00:01:04,429
Now!
Call 999!
20
00:01:05,597 --> 00:01:07,231
Now!!!
21
00:01:11,502 --> 00:01:14,638
Mr Raines, you'll be allowed to
carry your son to the ambulance
22
00:01:14,705 --> 00:01:16,873
and hold him on the
way to the hospital.
23
00:01:16,941 --> 00:01:18,809
You'll both be able to stay with him
24
00:01:18,876 --> 00:01:21,311
for as long as you need to.
Thank you.
25
00:01:21,378 --> 00:01:23,012
Where's my baby?
Where's Alex?
26
00:01:23,080 --> 00:01:25,815
Where is he?
Suzy.
27
00:01:25,882 --> 00:01:28,016
No.
28
00:01:28,084 --> 00:01:29,919
No...
No, don't.
29
00:01:29,986 --> 00:01:31,854
Don't!
Don't!
30
00:01:33,222 --> 00:01:34,557
( Suzy sobbing loudly )
31
00:01:34,624 --> 00:01:37,259
No! No!
32
00:01:41,464 --> 00:01:44,766
Clear signs of
encephalopathy, intracranial
33
00:01:44,834 --> 00:01:47,168
and intraocular bleeding.
I thought it was cot death.
34
00:01:47,235 --> 00:01:49,270
It's not.
That's why I've called you in.
35
00:01:49,338 --> 00:01:51,940
He has the typical triad
of injuries seen in
36
00:01:52,007 --> 00:01:54,476
shaken baby syndrome.
So you're saying someone shook him?
37
00:01:54,543 --> 00:01:57,410
Well, I checked for everything else.
38
00:01:57,479 --> 00:01:59,746
And the time of death was
between 7 and 9 P.M.?
39
00:01:59,814 --> 00:02:01,181
Yes, but the abuse could have occurred
40
00:02:01,248 --> 00:02:04,117
any time in the last
12 hours of his life.
41
00:02:04,185 --> 00:02:06,720
So working back from time of death,
42
00:02:06,788 --> 00:02:08,755
someone could have shook the baby at,
say, 7 o'clock yesterday morning
43
00:02:08,823 --> 00:02:10,824
and it would have took him 12 hours to die?
It's possible.
44
00:02:10,892 --> 00:02:14,861
You ask me, someone picked that baby
up and shook it for all it's worth.
45
00:02:18,231 --> 00:02:23,633
www.addic7ed.com
Adriano_CSI
46
00:03:00,139 --> 00:03:02,305
this baby monitor is
state-of-the-art stuff.
47
00:03:02,373 --> 00:03:03,540
Breathing sensor,
48
00:03:03,607 --> 00:03:05,375
camera, recording device.
49
00:03:05,443 --> 00:03:07,810
Was there a video recording
of that night? There was,
50
00:03:07,878 --> 00:03:10,780
but when the monitor switched off, it
automatically deletes the last recording
51
00:03:10,848 --> 00:03:12,349
unless you press "save."
52
00:03:12,417 --> 00:03:14,151
Is there a way to
retrieve the recording?
53
00:03:14,218 --> 00:03:17,186
I can't, but I know a man who
can if he has the hard drive.
54
00:03:17,254 --> 00:03:20,156
Might take a while, though.
Get onto it straightaway.
55
00:03:20,223 --> 00:03:22,525
Do we know who had access to the baby?
56
00:03:22,592 --> 00:03:26,162
Suzanne Raines hands the
baby over to the nanny
57
00:03:26,229 --> 00:03:28,230
and then leaves for work at 7:30.
58
00:03:28,298 --> 00:03:30,132
But that's all it
takes... half an hour.
59
00:03:30,200 --> 00:03:32,634
Mum's running late for work,
the baby holds her up,
60
00:03:32,702 --> 00:03:34,302
she loses her rag...
Hang on.
61
00:03:34,370 --> 00:03:36,671
Mum's not the only one
with access to the baby.
62
00:03:36,738 --> 00:03:39,207
In most cases of sbs, like it or not,
63
00:03:39,275 --> 00:03:41,076
the mum is the prime suspect.
64
00:03:41,143 --> 00:03:44,312
That's because most of the time
the mum is the main caregiver,
65
00:03:44,380 --> 00:03:45,547
but that's not the case here.
66
00:03:45,614 --> 00:03:46,948
Yeah, there was a nanny, right?
67
00:03:47,015 --> 00:03:49,816
Yeah. She is live-in, but no
formal childcare training.
68
00:03:49,884 --> 00:03:52,586
All right.
Talk to the parents first,
69
00:03:52,653 --> 00:03:55,222
but go easy on them, boys.
70
00:03:58,826 --> 00:04:01,895
All new mums and dads worry
about cot death, don't they?
71
00:04:01,963 --> 00:04:03,763
The first few weeks I
was up half the night
72
00:04:03,831 --> 00:04:05,531
checking he was still breathing.
73
00:04:05,599 --> 00:04:07,666
That's why we got the monitor.
74
00:04:07,734 --> 00:04:10,403
They're supposed to be
safe after six months.
75
00:04:10,471 --> 00:04:13,439
When we found out that it was more
likely to happen to boys than girls
76
00:04:13,507 --> 00:04:15,241
we read up about it.
77
00:04:15,309 --> 00:04:17,076
And we always put him on his back,
78
00:04:17,144 --> 00:04:18,777
and we never left him to cry.
79
00:04:18,845 --> 00:04:21,279
We don't think it's cot death.
80
00:04:22,548 --> 00:04:25,016
Is that what all this is about?
81
00:04:25,084 --> 00:04:27,919
There was bleeding in Alex's brain.
82
00:04:27,987 --> 00:04:29,921
Sorry. Bleeding, how?
83
00:04:29,989 --> 00:04:32,357
Someone shook him.
Suzy: No.
84
00:04:32,425 --> 00:04:33,658
There must be some mistake.
85
00:04:33,726 --> 00:04:35,360
( Cellphone rings )
86
00:04:35,428 --> 00:04:37,794
It's work.
I have to take this.
87
00:04:37,862 --> 00:04:41,332
Just let it go to voicemail, Suzy.
I can't.
88
00:04:41,399 --> 00:04:43,367
( Clears throat ) Yes?
89
00:04:43,435 --> 00:04:46,003
For God's sake, love.
Well, can't someone else?
90
00:04:46,070 --> 00:04:48,305
No... okay.
No, fine.
91
00:04:48,373 --> 00:04:50,040
I'll deal with it.
92
00:04:52,444 --> 00:04:55,011
So much for compassionate leave, eh?
93
00:04:57,414 --> 00:04:58,748
Matt: You must be under
a lot of pressure.
94
00:04:58,815 --> 00:05:02,318
I mean, demanding boss, little baby...
95
00:05:02,386 --> 00:05:03,486
Sorry, but what are you getting at?
96
00:05:03,554 --> 00:05:05,888
It's perfectly understandable.
97
00:05:05,956 --> 00:05:08,191
A lot of new mums don't realize
how hard it's gonna be.
98
00:05:08,259 --> 00:05:10,392
No, no, no.
Don't you dare.
99
00:05:10,460 --> 00:05:13,562
You know, my wife spends every
lunch break in the toilet
100
00:05:13,630 --> 00:05:17,066
expressing milk so she can
still breast-feed Alex.
101
00:05:17,134 --> 00:05:19,601
Does that sound like a mum
who wants to hurt her kid?
102
00:05:19,670 --> 00:05:21,436
Mr Raines...
103
00:05:21,504 --> 00:05:24,406
We have to ask these questions.
104
00:05:24,474 --> 00:05:30,411
Leila told us that she normally
takes over around 7:30.
105
00:05:30,479 --> 00:05:33,682
Can you remember what time you handed
the baby over to her yesterday morning?
106
00:05:33,749 --> 00:05:37,218
She got him up after I left for work.
107
00:05:37,286 --> 00:05:40,689
I had to be in the office at six
to take an international caller.
108
00:05:40,756 --> 00:05:43,190
I'm selling some flats
for an overseas client.
109
00:05:43,257 --> 00:05:46,359
I didn't even open the door.
110
00:05:46,427 --> 00:05:48,862
And what about you, sir?
111
00:05:48,930 --> 00:05:51,765
Did you see Alex
before you went work?
112
00:05:51,833 --> 00:05:53,433
No.
113
00:05:53,501 --> 00:05:56,904
No, I was away in Manchester
on business overnight.
114
00:05:56,971 --> 00:05:59,005
I got back, um, I don't know,
115
00:05:59,073 --> 00:06:01,373
a minute, two minutes
before I found him.
116
00:06:01,441 --> 00:06:03,776
Right.
117
00:06:03,844 --> 00:06:06,278
Other than yourselves and the nanny,
118
00:06:06,346 --> 00:06:08,981
does anyone else have
access to the house?
119
00:06:09,049 --> 00:06:11,784
My husband's ex-wife has a key.
120
00:06:13,786 --> 00:06:17,522
Andrea and I share an
online jewelry busine.
121
00:06:17,590 --> 00:06:18,857
The office is here in the house.
122
00:06:18,925 --> 00:06:21,925
And was she here yesterday?
123
00:06:22,138 --> 00:06:24,906
- I was in luton looking at samples.
- All day?
124
00:06:24,974 --> 00:06:27,941
It was a big order.
The supplier wanted to take me out for lunch.
125
00:06:28,010 --> 00:06:31,078
We're old friends.
I can give you his contact details.
126
00:06:31,146 --> 00:06:33,047
Then I got back early evening,
127
00:06:33,115 --> 00:06:35,916
and it was just me, emmerdale,
and a bottle of wine.
128
00:06:35,984 --> 00:06:38,152
Could anyone have got
hold of your keys?
129
00:06:38,220 --> 00:06:39,586
No, I had them with me.
130
00:06:39,654 --> 00:06:41,889
Does Suzanne Raines mind
you working with Michael?
131
00:06:41,956 --> 00:06:43,990
We're all grown-ups.
132
00:06:44,058 --> 00:06:46,359
Look, it's that nanny of theirs
you should be talking to.
133
00:06:46,427 --> 00:06:49,629
You do know about the time
she overdosed the baby?
134
00:06:49,696 --> 00:06:51,197
Ronnie: A couple of months ago
135
00:06:51,265 --> 00:06:53,866
leila turned up at accident
and emergency with baby Alex
136
00:06:53,934 --> 00:06:56,136
because he overdosed on calpol.
137
00:06:56,203 --> 00:06:57,437
And how does a four-month-old baby
138
00:06:57,505 --> 00:06:59,438
get the top off a bottle of calpol?
139
00:06:59,506 --> 00:07:01,940
Leila had given him the maximum dosage
140
00:07:02,008 --> 00:07:03,642
meant for babies over one year old.
141
00:07:03,709 --> 00:07:06,045
She repeated the
dosage one hour later.
142
00:07:06,112 --> 00:07:07,946
She obviously realized
what she'd done,
143
00:07:08,014 --> 00:07:10,082
panicked after reading the bottle.
144
00:07:10,150 --> 00:07:11,983
And the parents never mentioned this?
145
00:07:12,052 --> 00:07:14,318
Well, Alex was absolutely fine.
146
00:07:14,386 --> 00:07:18,022
One mistake, all right, but two
months later the baby ends up dead?
147
00:07:18,090 --> 00:07:20,525
See what our nanny has to say.
148
00:07:20,592 --> 00:07:22,326
I didn't read the bottle properly.
149
00:07:22,394 --> 00:07:25,096
You gave him a second dose
less than an hour later?
150
00:07:25,164 --> 00:07:28,299
I was tired. I forgot I'd
even given him the first lot.
151
00:07:28,367 --> 00:07:29,700
Soon as I realized what I'd done,
152
00:07:29,768 --> 00:07:31,234
I took up up to the hospital.
153
00:07:31,302 --> 00:07:33,970
And it says hereyou got hime
154
00:07:34,038 --> 00:07:36,873
at around 10 A.M., yeah?
He was teething.
155
00:07:36,941 --> 00:07:38,942
Suzanne was away at some work thing.
156
00:07:39,009 --> 00:07:40,944
I'd been up with him half the night.
157
00:07:41,011 --> 00:07:42,379
So you were stressed out.
158
00:07:42,447 --> 00:07:44,181
Too right I was.
159
00:07:44,248 --> 00:07:47,149
Suzanne only used homeopathic
stuff on him when he was unwell.
160
00:07:47,217 --> 00:07:49,351
Said she was worried about e
e numbers in kids medicine.
161
00:07:49,419 --> 00:07:51,620
Well, that's a parent's choice.
162
00:07:51,688 --> 00:07:55,057
She wasn't the one stuck in the house
all day with a screaming baby.
163
00:07:55,125 --> 00:07:56,658
So you went against her wishes.
164
00:07:56,726 --> 00:07:59,428
She was into all that hippie shit.
165
00:07:59,496 --> 00:08:03,364
You can't do attachment parenting
if you work 12 hours a day.
166
00:08:03,432 --> 00:08:06,568
I gave Alex the calpol so
I could get some sleep.
167
00:08:06,635 --> 00:08:09,404
Well, maybe you wanted some
sleep the night Alex died.
168
00:08:09,472 --> 00:08:12,039
No. You'd been up with
the child since six,
169
00:08:12,108 --> 00:08:14,809
you must have been exhausted.
170
00:08:14,876 --> 00:08:17,579
I didn't hurt him.
Well, leila,
171
00:08:17,646 --> 00:08:21,081
you were the only one who had access
to baby Alex the day he died.
172
00:08:21,149 --> 00:08:23,283
And you were the one who
switched the baby monitor off.
173
00:08:23,351 --> 00:08:26,153
I didn't.
It must have been faulty.
174
00:08:26,221 --> 00:08:28,722
Mr Raines said your door was closed
175
00:08:28,789 --> 00:08:31,958
- and music was blaring.
- Alex was asleep.
176
00:08:32,026 --> 00:08:33,627
How would you know if the
monitor had been turned off?
177
00:08:33,694 --> 00:08:36,129
His room was below mine.
I would have heard him.
178
00:08:36,196 --> 00:08:38,498
Over the music?
He cried loud.
179
00:08:38,565 --> 00:08:40,199
Dead babies don't cry.
180
00:08:40,267 --> 00:08:43,269
I didn't know he was dead, did I?
181
00:08:43,337 --> 00:08:46,071
He was always kicking off lately.
182
00:08:46,140 --> 00:08:48,574
If he wasn't, he was asleep.
183
00:08:48,642 --> 00:08:50,075
And what do you usually do
184
00:08:50,143 --> 00:08:52,144
if he was to, as you say, kick off?
185
00:08:52,211 --> 00:08:55,013
Check the monitor, wait a bit,
then go and settle him.
186
00:08:55,080 --> 00:08:56,314
How long is a "bit"?
187
00:08:56,382 --> 00:08:59,117
I dunno.
Depends how tired I am.
188
00:08:59,185 --> 00:09:01,286
Five minutes? Ten?
189
00:09:03,088 --> 00:09:04,722
What's the big deal?
190
00:09:04,790 --> 00:09:07,057
Everyone does controlled crying.
191
00:09:07,125 --> 00:09:09,160
Well, mrs Raines specifically told us
192
00:09:09,227 --> 00:09:11,928
that she disapproved of it.
193
00:09:11,996 --> 00:09:13,631
When my girls couldn't settle,
194
00:09:13,698 --> 00:09:15,799
I just used to walk 'em up and
down the hall half the night.
195
00:09:15,867 --> 00:09:18,335
Leaving a baby to cry it
out isn't abusive, Ron.
196
00:09:18,403 --> 00:09:20,337
When you've had a kid, you
come back and tell me that.
197
00:09:20,405 --> 00:09:22,338
Babies need to learn the
difference between night and day.
198
00:09:22,406 --> 00:09:25,141
Comes a time when you say
they're fed, they're dry,
199
00:09:25,209 --> 00:09:26,876
it's time they went to sleep.
200
00:09:26,943 --> 00:09:29,546
Controlled crying teaches
babies to sleep by themselves.
201
00:09:29,613 --> 00:09:31,147
It teaches babies that mum and dad
202
00:09:31,215 --> 00:09:33,316
ain't coming no matter
how loud they cry.
203
00:09:33,384 --> 00:09:35,851
It's the only way
babies can communicate.
204
00:09:35,919 --> 00:09:39,020
Exactly. Could be saying, "I
want to play peep-o" at 3 A.M.
205
00:09:39,088 --> 00:09:41,089
Or they could be
saying, "I'm in pain."
206
00:09:41,157 --> 00:09:42,724
I wouldn't leave you
crying in another room
207
00:09:42,792 --> 00:09:43,958
and not go to you, would I?
208
00:09:44,026 --> 00:09:45,260
If you ever see me crying,
209
00:09:45,328 --> 00:09:46,695
please make sure you do.
Ohh.
210
00:09:46,762 --> 00:09:48,797
When you've finished debating
parenting techniques,
211
00:09:48,864 --> 00:09:51,099
perhaps you'd talk to the last
people who employed leila
212
00:09:51,167 --> 00:09:53,868
and see if their kid had
any visits to casualty.
213
00:09:56,238 --> 00:09:59,674
My boss kept finding me crying
all over the customers.
214
00:09:59,741 --> 00:10:03,077
( Baby coos ) Being away
from you was torture.
215
00:10:03,144 --> 00:10:06,414
You didn't trust leila
to look after Mia?
216
00:10:06,481 --> 00:10:08,482
Well, you hear all
these horror stories,
217
00:10:08,550 --> 00:10:10,883
nannies who shove the kid
in front of the telly
218
00:10:10,951 --> 00:10:13,653
and spend all day on the
phone to their mates.
219
00:10:13,721 --> 00:10:15,088
So was leila like that?
220
00:10:15,155 --> 00:10:17,857
You don't know what goes on
when you're out at work.
221
00:10:17,925 --> 00:10:19,959
And was something going on?
222
00:10:20,027 --> 00:10:23,129
She used to spend the whole
evening on her laptop.
223
00:10:23,197 --> 00:10:25,732
I started worrying she
was on it all day, too.
224
00:10:25,799 --> 00:10:28,934
So I borrowed one of those
nanny cams from a friend.
225
00:10:29,001 --> 00:10:31,136
And did you see leila hurt Mia?
226
00:10:31,204 --> 00:10:34,573
No, I could hear
Mia shut in her bedroom,
227
00:10:34,641 --> 00:10:37,175
crying her little heart out.
228
00:10:37,244 --> 00:10:41,146
Leila was on my sofa...
Having sex with her boyfriend.
229
00:10:45,952 --> 00:10:49,420
I managed to access leila's email
and social networking accounts.
230
00:10:49,488 --> 00:10:52,891
She met her boyfriend Lloyd
on a social networking site
231
00:10:52,959 --> 00:10:54,826
for squaddies and their families.
232
00:10:54,894 --> 00:10:57,129
He's stationed out in Afghanistan.
233
00:10:57,196 --> 00:11:00,798
Well, if he's out there, how many
times did they actually meet?
234
00:11:00,866 --> 00:11:03,567
Only a handful, but this is the
longest they've been apart.
235
00:11:03,635 --> 00:11:05,035
So it was serious.
236
00:11:05,103 --> 00:11:06,937
Well, you tell me.
237
00:11:07,005 --> 00:11:09,439
"Can't wait to rip your clothes off
238
00:11:09,507 --> 00:11:11,475
"and show how much I missed you.
239
00:11:11,542 --> 00:11:15,245
"Had this really dirty dream
about you last night.
240
00:11:15,312 --> 00:11:17,781
"I had you tied to my bed.
241
00:11:17,848 --> 00:11:19,215
"I was in control,
242
00:11:19,283 --> 00:11:21,017
"and you were begging me to touch you,
243
00:11:21,085 --> 00:11:22,886
yes, ang, we get the point.
And to make you"...
244
00:11:22,953 --> 00:11:25,621
Thank you.
The emails are nothing.
245
00:11:25,689 --> 00:11:28,658
I checked the media files and found...
246
00:11:28,725 --> 00:11:29,826
This.
247
00:11:31,627 --> 00:11:32,460
( Chuckles )
248
00:11:35,198 --> 00:11:38,667
Well, maybe they wanted something
to remember each other by
249
00:11:38,734 --> 00:11:40,402
when they're apart.
250
00:11:40,469 --> 00:11:42,037
A passport photo in your wallet
251
00:11:42,105 --> 00:11:43,705
used to do the trick
when I was a teenager.
252
00:11:43,773 --> 00:11:46,041
Can you tell when this made?
253
00:11:46,109 --> 00:11:49,743
Down to the second.
It was made the night the baby died.
254
00:11:49,812 --> 00:11:52,046
Recording started at 8:21
255
00:11:52,114 --> 00:11:54,949
and then finished at quarter to 9:00
256
00:11:55,017 --> 00:11:57,785
when leila heard Michael
Raines come home.
257
00:11:57,853 --> 00:12:00,121
So these two were making porn movies
258
00:12:00,189 --> 00:12:02,389
while the baby lies dead in his cot.
259
00:12:02,457 --> 00:12:04,624
Any mention of the baby in
the emails the day he died?
260
00:12:04,692 --> 00:12:06,592
One.
261
00:12:06,660 --> 00:12:10,163
This was sent two hours before
they turned the webcam on.
262
00:12:10,231 --> 00:12:11,798
"Michael's train delayed.
263
00:12:11,866 --> 00:12:14,400
"Bitch at work as usual,
so no night off.
264
00:12:14,468 --> 00:12:17,204
"They aren't gonna ruin this for us.
You come here,
265
00:12:17,271 --> 00:12:20,673
I'll make sure the baby
doesn't get in the way."
266
00:12:22,710 --> 00:12:24,510
I didn't think it was important.
267
00:12:24,578 --> 00:12:26,346
He was in the house
when Alex died.
268
00:12:26,413 --> 00:12:28,147
Lloyd wouldn't have hurt Alex.
269
00:12:28,215 --> 00:12:29,615
He wouldn't hurt anyone.
270
00:12:29,683 --> 00:12:31,884
What time did he come round?
271
00:12:31,952 --> 00:12:34,587
Not till after I put Alex to bed.
272
00:12:34,655 --> 00:12:37,689
Now, you said Alex had
cried a couple of times.
273
00:12:37,757 --> 00:12:41,159
Was that before or after
Lloyd arrived at the house?
274
00:12:45,398 --> 00:12:49,234
Leila, we need to know
the truth, please.
275
00:12:49,301 --> 00:12:51,236
Just after Lloyd
276
00:12:51,303 --> 00:12:55,539
got round, I went upstairs,
rocked Alex back to sleep.
277
00:12:55,607 --> 00:12:57,675
I got to the bottom of the
stairs, and he woke up again.
278
00:12:57,743 --> 00:12:59,276
And you got angry.
279
00:12:59,344 --> 00:13:02,613
At Michael and Suzanne,
yeah, not at Alex.
280
00:13:02,681 --> 00:13:05,449
But Alex was the one ruining the
reunion with the boyfriend.
281
00:13:05,517 --> 00:13:08,150
I didn't hurt him.
I wouldn't have.
282
00:13:08,218 --> 00:13:09,252
So who did?
I dunno.
283
00:13:09,319 --> 00:13:10,854
I swear.
284
00:13:10,921 --> 00:13:12,856
Did Lloyd have any contact
285
00:13:12,923 --> 00:13:14,323
with the baby?
286
00:13:15,860 --> 00:13:17,427
Leila, we need to know.
287
00:13:19,062 --> 00:13:21,598
He wasn't in there long.
288
00:13:21,665 --> 00:13:25,334
He said he used to get his baby
brother to sleep all the time.
289
00:13:25,402 --> 00:13:27,303
Matt: No criminal record,
290
00:13:27,371 --> 00:13:29,671
he's been in the army
since he left school.
291
00:13:29,739 --> 00:13:31,774
Been stationed in Afghanistan
for the last five months.
292
00:13:31,841 --> 00:13:33,009
He's one of the peacekeepers.
293
00:13:33,076 --> 00:13:34,310
Only he's not that good at it.
294
00:13:34,378 --> 00:13:36,512
Lloyd Benson's been the
subject of a disciplinary.
295
00:13:36,579 --> 00:13:38,347
Put another squaddie in hospital.
296
00:13:38,415 --> 00:13:40,315
Have you seen his family history?
297
00:13:40,383 --> 00:13:43,118
Yeah, grew up in Camden, mum and
dad split up a few years back.
298
00:13:43,185 --> 00:13:45,787
Two older sisters.
There was a baby brother.
299
00:13:45,854 --> 00:13:48,423
Was? Yeah, the baby died
at three months old.
300
00:13:48,490 --> 00:13:50,358
Postmortem couldn't
find cause of death,
301
00:13:50,426 --> 00:13:52,994
so it was classed as sudden
infant death syndrome.
302
00:13:53,062 --> 00:13:56,062
And guess who was baby-sitting?
303
00:14:02,371 --> 00:14:03,805
That's him.
304
00:14:05,407 --> 00:14:07,475
Lloyd Benson, I'm arresting you
305
00:14:07,543 --> 00:14:09,810
on suspicion of the murder
of Alexander Raines.
306
00:14:09,878 --> 00:14:11,111
You do not have to say anything,
307
00:14:11,179 --> 00:14:13,147
but it may harm your defence...
You're joking.
308
00:14:13,215 --> 00:14:15,615
No joke, son.
309
00:14:15,683 --> 00:14:20,020
Lloyd: Dante's death tore
my family apart. I bet.
310
00:14:20,088 --> 00:14:21,521
Did your family blame you?
311
00:14:21,589 --> 00:14:23,457
He was fourteen years old.
312
00:14:23,524 --> 00:14:25,358
Well, dealing with a crying baby
313
00:14:25,425 --> 00:14:27,093
isn't easy for an adult, is it?
314
00:14:27,161 --> 00:14:29,329
But I mean, you were just a kid.
315
00:14:29,396 --> 00:14:32,598
I never hurt my brother, and I
never hurt this kid neither.
316
00:14:32,666 --> 00:14:36,202
Leila said that you went into the
baby's room to settle him down.
317
00:14:36,270 --> 00:14:37,837
What time would that have been?
318
00:14:37,905 --> 00:14:39,339
Dunno. Eight-ish?
319
00:14:39,406 --> 00:14:41,773
And why didn't
she go in to him?
320
00:14:41,841 --> 00:14:43,675
She'd been in there five times.
321
00:14:43,743 --> 00:14:46,078
Every time she left the room
the baby kicked off again.
322
00:14:46,145 --> 00:14:48,713
So you thought you'd have a go?
Yeah.
323
00:14:48,781 --> 00:14:51,516
And how did you do that?
Settle him down, I mean.
324
00:14:51,584 --> 00:14:54,953
I sang him blackbird
by the Beatles.
325
00:14:55,021 --> 00:14:56,988
My mum used to sing it to me.
326
00:14:57,055 --> 00:15:00,758
Look, I just wanted to
be with my girlfriend.
327
00:15:00,825 --> 00:15:03,060
To get back to making
some more home movies?
328
00:15:05,530 --> 00:15:07,298
It was only for us.
329
00:15:07,366 --> 00:15:09,700
But the baby got in
the way, nonetheless.
330
00:15:09,768 --> 00:15:11,235
No... yeah...
331
00:15:13,704 --> 00:15:16,639
You must be under a lot
of pressure, Lloyd.
332
00:15:16,707 --> 00:15:18,275
I mean, what with Afghanistan
333
00:15:18,342 --> 00:15:19,609
and all the rest that goes with it.
334
00:15:19,676 --> 00:15:21,477
You have no idea.
335
00:15:21,545 --> 00:15:25,115
I fail to see how private
Benson's job is relevant.
336
00:15:25,182 --> 00:15:28,050
Well, the relevance of
private Benson's job
337
00:15:28,118 --> 00:15:31,586
is the fact thathe attacked
a fr of his regiment...
338
00:15:31,654 --> 00:15:34,556
I was trying to break up a
fight, defending my mate.
339
00:15:34,624 --> 00:15:37,459
That is what you're trained to do,
though, isn't it? Defend others?
340
00:15:37,527 --> 00:15:39,295
Yes?
341
00:15:39,362 --> 00:15:43,065
Even kill, if necessary.
Insurgents, not babies.
342
00:15:43,133 --> 00:15:44,966
Here's what I think happened, Lloyd.
343
00:15:45,034 --> 00:15:46,968
I think you went in
to that baby's room
344
00:15:47,036 --> 00:15:49,170
to help settle him down,
and it didn't work.
345
00:15:49,171 --> 00:15:51,605
No. I told you... and then
maybe he cried some more,
346
00:15:51,673 --> 00:15:53,341
leila was getting upset with you,
347
00:15:53,409 --> 00:15:55,676
it spoiled the moment
for the pair of you,
348
00:15:55,744 --> 00:15:58,079
and maybe you lost your temper.
349
00:15:58,147 --> 00:16:00,080
Yeah, it spoiled the
mood, leila was upset,
350
00:16:00,148 --> 00:16:03,850
but the only thing making
me lose my temper is you!
351
00:16:05,820 --> 00:16:07,187
Sit down, son.
352
00:16:11,960 --> 00:16:13,994
Lloyd wouldn't hurt a baby.
353
00:16:14,062 --> 00:16:16,228
You know his baby brother
died, though, right?
354
00:16:16,296 --> 00:16:18,164
What?
Yeah, he was three months old.
355
00:16:18,231 --> 00:16:20,933
Found dead in his cot.
Lloyd was baby-sitting.
356
00:16:21,001 --> 00:16:23,535
You're lying.
357
00:16:26,706 --> 00:16:30,242
The death certificate said it was
sudden infant death syndrome,
358
00:16:30,310 --> 00:16:32,210
but it wouldn't be the first time that
359
00:16:32,278 --> 00:16:35,413
a cot death turned out to be murder.
No way.
360
00:16:35,481 --> 00:16:37,515
Lloyd's proper close to his family.
361
00:16:37,583 --> 00:16:39,817
It's a bit of a coincidence
though, isn't it?
362
00:16:39,885 --> 00:16:42,454
Two dead babies,
363
00:16:42,521 --> 00:16:46,458
and Lloyd is there alone
with both of them.
364
00:16:46,525 --> 00:16:49,193
Maybe you don't know him quite
as well as you think you do.
365
00:16:51,596 --> 00:16:55,665
Lloyd was alone in that room with Alex.
You said it yourself.
366
00:16:55,733 --> 00:17:01,338
Now, someone got angry that night...
367
00:17:01,406 --> 00:17:04,474
And someone shook that baby.
368
00:17:06,576 --> 00:17:10,846
And if it wasn't you, then...
369
00:17:10,914 --> 00:17:12,948
It must have been Lloyd.
370
00:17:18,722 --> 00:17:22,057
We were in my room.
Playing music.
371
00:17:22,125 --> 00:17:24,859
Alex's crying was doing my nut in
372
00:17:24,927 --> 00:17:28,163
so I put the parent unit on silent.
373
00:17:28,231 --> 00:17:33,068
The lights flash up and the screen
comes on when the baby cries.
374
00:17:33,136 --> 00:17:36,170
The lights were flashing like
mad when Lloyd went in there.
375
00:17:36,238 --> 00:17:38,372
Then they just stopped.
376
00:17:42,644 --> 00:17:45,146
Lloyd said he'd settled him.
377
00:17:45,213 --> 00:17:47,948
He said Alex was fast asleep.
378
00:17:53,087 --> 00:17:56,489
I used to know every squeaky
floorboard in my girls' room.
379
00:17:56,557 --> 00:18:00,160
Step on the wrong one, and bang
goes an hour rocking them to sleep.
380
00:18:00,227 --> 00:18:03,329
But you didn't know
Alex's room, Lloyd.
381
00:18:03,397 --> 00:18:05,798
One false move and he's
bawling his head off again.
382
00:18:05,866 --> 00:18:07,567
I was on my way out.
383
00:18:09,235 --> 00:18:11,236
I'd only just closed the door.
384
00:18:11,304 --> 00:18:13,238
And it woke him up?
385
00:18:13,306 --> 00:18:15,507
Must have been the light in the
hall when I opened the door.
386
00:18:15,575 --> 00:18:19,244
Right. Which one of you two
went back into the room?
387
00:18:19,312 --> 00:18:21,880
Was it you or leila?
388
00:18:24,583 --> 00:18:26,150
Lloyd...
389
00:18:28,187 --> 00:18:32,523
Lloyd, the baby monitor
in Alex's bedroom
390
00:18:32,591 --> 00:18:35,526
had a camera with a recording device.
391
00:18:35,594 --> 00:18:38,496
And we have people working
on that hard drive,
392
00:18:38,564 --> 00:18:40,430
retrieving that recording.
393
00:18:40,498 --> 00:18:42,966
So pretty soon we're
gonna be able to see
394
00:18:43,033 --> 00:18:46,169
when that baby was in
and out of that cot.
395
00:18:46,237 --> 00:18:49,272
And we're gonna be able
to hear every sound
396
00:18:49,340 --> 00:18:52,342
from that room on that night.
397
00:18:52,410 --> 00:18:55,345
You're gonna make me
wait for those results?
398
00:18:55,413 --> 00:18:59,047
Or are you gonna tell me now what I'm
gonna see and hear from that recording?
399
00:19:01,918 --> 00:19:03,119
Lloyd.
400
00:19:04,321 --> 00:19:07,022
Leila went back in.
401
00:19:07,090 --> 00:19:10,692
Started shouting at him,
told him to shut up.
402
00:19:10,760 --> 00:19:13,094
She just completely lost it.
403
00:19:14,896 --> 00:19:17,365
I went in after her.
404
00:19:17,433 --> 00:19:19,501
The baby was in the cot screaming.
405
00:19:21,370 --> 00:19:23,871
I told leila I'd sort it.
406
00:19:23,939 --> 00:19:26,541
So did you pick the baby up?
407
00:19:28,043 --> 00:19:29,743
Did you pick the baby up again?
408
00:19:29,810 --> 00:19:31,512
No. I should have.
409
00:19:31,579 --> 00:19:34,148
I knew if he kept crying then
leila wouldn't want to...
410
00:19:34,215 --> 00:19:36,016
What, have sex?
411
00:19:38,253 --> 00:19:40,420
So what did you do?
412
00:19:41,589 --> 00:19:43,257
What did you do, Lloyd?
413
00:19:43,324 --> 00:19:45,691
I turned it off.
414
00:19:45,759 --> 00:19:48,294
I turned the baby monitor off.
415
00:19:53,967 --> 00:19:55,668
They're gonna stick to their stories.
416
00:19:55,735 --> 00:19:57,936
We're not gonna get a confession
out of either of them.
417
00:19:58,004 --> 00:19:59,372
It could be either one of 'em.
418
00:19:59,439 --> 00:20:01,239
We got the medical
evidence and the laptop.
419
00:20:01,307 --> 00:20:03,475
We're just waiting on the recording
from the baby monitor now.
420
00:20:03,543 --> 00:20:04,909
He puts her in the baby's room,
421
00:20:04,977 --> 00:20:07,011
she puts him in there too.
It's enough.
422
00:20:07,079 --> 00:20:09,914
So which one of them do
you want us to charge?
423
00:20:09,982 --> 00:20:13,585
We charge both of them with
murder on a joint enterprise.
424
00:20:13,653 --> 00:20:16,453
Private Benson has no
previous convictions
425
00:20:16,521 --> 00:20:18,755
and an exemplary military record.
426
00:20:18,823 --> 00:20:20,991
My lord, he was recently stripped
of the rank of Lance corporal,
427
00:20:21,059 --> 00:20:23,360
having been found guilty of
attacking a fellow soldier.
428
00:20:23,428 --> 00:20:26,029
There is also the issue of
his baby brother's death.
429
00:20:26,097 --> 00:20:28,832
His brother died of sudden
infant death syndrome.
430
00:20:28,900 --> 00:20:31,134
There is no evidence
whatsoever the death
431
00:20:31,203 --> 00:20:34,170
was anything but natural.
I've heard enough.
432
00:20:34,238 --> 00:20:38,174
Ms marsden, I assume you want to
make a bail application, too.
433
00:20:38,242 --> 00:20:40,042
Indeed, my lord.
434
00:20:40,110 --> 00:20:41,977
As you know, there is much debate
435
00:20:42,045 --> 00:20:45,415
as to whether prison is a suitable
environment for women full stop,
436
00:20:45,482 --> 00:20:49,284
let alone a vulnerable teenager
with no previous convictions.
437
00:20:49,352 --> 00:20:51,120
And nowhere to be bailed to.
438
00:20:51,188 --> 00:20:53,022
She was residing with
the victim's parents.
439
00:20:53,090 --> 00:20:55,324
She can reside with her parents.
440
00:20:55,391 --> 00:20:56,658
I'm sorry, ms marsden,
441
00:20:56,727 --> 00:20:59,195
your client is charged
with the brutal murder
442
00:20:59,262 --> 00:21:00,863
of a defenseless baby.
443
00:21:00,931 --> 00:21:02,832
I'm not taking any chances.
444
00:21:02,899 --> 00:21:05,834
Both defendants are
remanded in custody.
445
00:21:07,570 --> 00:21:10,539
Oh, come on, Helena,
what did you expect?
446
00:21:10,607 --> 00:21:11,806
Oh, I don't know.
447
00:21:11,874 --> 00:21:14,909
A lile common sense, perhaps.
448
00:21:14,977 --> 00:21:17,011
Judges are understandably cautious
449
00:21:17,079 --> 00:21:19,248
about releasing child killers on bail.
450
00:21:19,315 --> 00:21:21,850
My client didn't kill that baby.
451
00:21:21,917 --> 00:21:23,551
The boyfriend, on the other hand,
452
00:21:23,619 --> 00:21:26,254
has history, motive, opportunity.
453
00:21:26,321 --> 00:21:28,289
You saw the email she sent him...
454
00:21:28,357 --> 00:21:30,358
"I'll make sure that baby
doesn't get in the way".
455
00:21:30,425 --> 00:21:31,559
Speaking of which...
456
00:21:31,627 --> 00:21:35,296
Application to exclude that laptop,
457
00:21:35,364 --> 00:21:38,764
the homemade porn, and the exchange
of messages you found on it.
458
00:21:40,533 --> 00:21:43,268
The laptop was seized
during an illegal search.
459
00:21:43,336 --> 00:21:45,971
Consent was obtained, my lord.
Not from my client.
460
00:21:46,039 --> 00:21:47,539
Michael Raines gave consent.
461
00:21:47,607 --> 00:21:49,540
It was his property,
Leila was his tenant.
462
00:21:49,608 --> 00:21:51,042
And also his employee.
463
00:21:51,110 --> 00:21:53,544
He can consent to a
search of her work area
464
00:21:53,612 --> 00:21:55,080
for items relating to her job,
465
00:21:55,147 --> 00:21:57,415
but her bedroom was
her rsrsonal space.
466
00:21:57,482 --> 00:22:00,284
Personal space belonging to
Michael and Suzanne Raines.
467
00:22:00,352 --> 00:22:02,520
I'm sorry, mr Steel,
468
00:22:02,588 --> 00:22:04,688
whether I own my bedroom
or rented it,
469
00:22:04,756 --> 00:22:08,592
I wouldn't want the pocece trawling
through my y-fronts without my consent.
470
00:22:08,693 --> 00:22:14,497
The evidence obtained from
the laptop is inadmissible
471
00:22:14,565 --> 00:22:17,034
James: All the medical evidence
proves is someone shook the baby.
472
00:22:17,102 --> 00:22:19,569
The video and the messages
between them provided motive.
473
00:22:19,637 --> 00:22:22,405
Well, the jury might
not get to see it,
474
00:22:22,506 --> 00:22:26,543
bu they will be told that those two
were having sex while that baby lay dying.
475
00:22:26,644 --> 00:22:28,712
Only one of them actually did it.
476
00:22:28,779 --> 00:22:30,614
Yes, but if both of them knew
what was happening,
477
00:22:30,715 --> 00:22:32,549
that makes them both guilt
478
00:22:32,650 --> 00:22:34,751
but we can't' prove
that they both knew
479
00:22:34,852 --> 00:22:38,621
and the jury will be scared of sending
an innocent person to prison.
480
00:22:38,688 --> 00:22:40,456
We're not gonna drop
the charges, James.
481
00:22:40,523 --> 00:22:42,057
No, I'm not suggesting we do.
482
00:22:42,125 --> 00:22:44,059
The defence will use the fact
483
00:22:44,127 --> 00:22:46,462
one provides reasonable
doubt for the other.
484
00:22:46,529 --> 00:22:48,530
So you'd rather just
go after one of them.
485
00:22:48,598 --> 00:22:52,433
If we can find out for certain
which one of them did it, yeah.
486
00:22:52,501 --> 00:22:56,638
The monitor recorded images and
sound the whole time it was on.
487
00:22:56,705 --> 00:22:58,640
You managed to retrieve it all?
Yep.
488
00:22:58,707 --> 00:23:01,108
A lot of baby Alex crying in his cot,
489
00:23:01,176 --> 00:23:04,345
leila coming in and out.
Anything incriminating?
490
00:23:04,413 --> 00:23:06,481
( Alex crying ) Lloyd:
Come on, you old man,
491
00:23:06,548 --> 00:23:09,048
i'm trying to get
some action in there
492
00:23:09,116 --> 00:23:10,517
( recording ends )
493
00:23:12,287 --> 00:23:13,920
Okay...
494
00:23:13,988 --> 00:23:16,956
Lloyd claims he turned
the baby monitor off,
495
00:23:17,024 --> 00:23:18,892
went into the bedroom,
had sex with leila,
496
00:23:18,959 --> 00:23:21,027
they were interrupted by
Michael Raines coming home,
497
00:23:21,095 --> 00:23:23,897
Lloyd climbs out of the
window onto the flat roof
498
00:23:23,964 --> 00:23:25,931
and makes his escape.
Right.
499
00:23:25,999 --> 00:23:28,534
So the recording proves
he was telling the truth.
500
00:23:28,602 --> 00:23:30,936
Could he have been in the
room any other time?
501
00:23:31,004 --> 00:23:32,305
Well, we know
502
00:23:32,372 --> 00:23:35,107
he only got to the house at 7:30.
503
00:23:35,175 --> 00:23:37,276
The recording starts at 6:00.
504
00:23:37,344 --> 00:23:38,778
He goes into the room,
505
00:23:38,845 --> 00:23:41,813
spends 20 minutes singing
the baby to sleep,
506
00:23:41,880 --> 00:23:44,215
then he's barely out the door
507
00:23:44,283 --> 00:23:46,484
when the baby starts crying again,
508
00:23:46,552 --> 00:23:49,321
and leila comes in.
( Alex crying )
509
00:23:49,388 --> 00:23:52,424
Leila: Just shut up, will you?!
You're spoiling everything!
510
00:23:52,491 --> 00:23:54,326
Shut up!!!
Lloyd: Leila, don't!
511
00:23:54,393 --> 00:23:56,260
Just go back in the bedroom.
I'll sort it.
512
00:23:56,328 --> 00:23:57,894
Poor kid.
513
00:23:57,962 --> 00:24:00,030
( Crying continues )
514
00:24:03,034 --> 00:24:06,537
Could he have shaken the baby
after he turned the monitor off?
515
00:24:06,604 --> 00:24:10,240
The timecode says the monitor went
off at 8:21 and 7 seconds exactly.
516
00:24:10,308 --> 00:24:13,643
19 seconds later Lloyd
turns on the webcam
517
00:24:13,711 --> 00:24:15,611
and appears in shot in leila's room,
518
00:24:15,679 --> 00:24:17,480
and they started their
homemade porn session.
519
00:24:17,548 --> 00:24:19,081
Just enough time to
go from Alex's room
520
00:24:19,149 --> 00:24:21,250
upstairs to leila's and
turn on the camera,
521
00:24:21,318 --> 00:24:23,753
but not enough time to
shake a baby to death.
522
00:24:23,821 --> 00:24:25,688
It can't have been Lloyd.
523
00:24:28,058 --> 00:24:31,092
The evidence we found
exonerates your client.
524
00:24:31,160 --> 00:24:32,861
We've issued a notice
of discontinuance
525
00:24:32,928 --> 00:24:34,796
and the court are drawing
up his release papers.
526
00:24:34,864 --> 00:24:36,598
I'll contact his family.
527
00:24:36,666 --> 00:24:39,267
I'm sure they'll want
the chance to see him
528
00:24:39,335 --> 00:24:42,136
before he flies back
out to Afghanistan.
529
00:24:46,608 --> 00:24:49,710
We're expecting a legal
visit with Lloyd Benson.
530
00:24:49,778 --> 00:24:53,547
I'm afraid that, uh,
won't be possible.
531
00:24:53,615 --> 00:24:56,150
I was assured private
Benson would be here.
532
00:24:56,218 --> 00:25:00,454
Lloyd Benson was stabbed by his
cellmate half an hour ago.
533
00:25:00,522 --> 00:25:03,156
He died before the ambulance arrived.
534
00:25:04,859 --> 00:25:09,229
This kid has done three
tours of Afghanistan....
535
00:25:09,297 --> 00:25:10,197
And he dies
536
00:25:10,265 --> 00:25:11,932
in one of your cells?
537
00:25:15,937 --> 00:25:18,737
You can't blame yourself
for this, James.
538
00:25:18,805 --> 00:25:21,007
Lloyd should never have
been in that prison cell.
539
00:25:21,074 --> 00:25:23,376
You weren't the only one
who thought he was guilty.
540
00:25:23,443 --> 00:25:25,044
He barely had access to that baby.
541
00:25:25,112 --> 00:25:27,280
It must have been leila.
542
00:25:27,347 --> 00:25:30,283
Lloyd's innocence does
prove leila's guilt.
543
00:25:30,350 --> 00:25:31,617
She was angry with that baby.
544
00:25:31,684 --> 00:25:32,885
You heard the recording.
545
00:25:32,952 --> 00:25:34,920
She was the only one with
opportunity and motive.
546
00:25:34,987 --> 00:25:38,256
Missing out on your night off is
hardly motive for child murder.
547
00:25:38,324 --> 00:25:41,459
She'd been caring for a teething
baby since 5:00 that morning.
548
00:25:41,527 --> 00:25:43,494
Come on, you're a parent,
you know what it's like.
549
00:25:43,562 --> 00:25:46,464
And most parents don't end up
killing their children, James.
550
00:25:46,532 --> 00:25:48,199
See you in court.
551
00:25:50,601 --> 00:25:51,802
You've got my report.
552
00:25:51,869 --> 00:25:53,637
I need you in the witness box, Lucy,
553
00:25:53,704 --> 00:25:56,340
your expert testimony could
make all the difference.
554
00:25:56,408 --> 00:25:58,642
There must be half a
dozen expert witnesses
555
00:25:58,709 --> 00:26:00,610
who'd be more than happy
to take the check.
556
00:26:00,678 --> 00:26:02,746
Yeah, but they didn't
do the postmortem.
557
00:26:02,814 --> 00:26:05,815
Well, these shaken baby cases
just aren't clear-cut anymore.
558
00:26:05,882 --> 00:26:08,584
You seemed to be pretty
clear about it before.
559
00:26:08,652 --> 00:26:10,920
I'm not disputing the baby was shaken.
560
00:26:10,988 --> 00:26:14,023
It's just I don't want a conviction
resting solely on my evidence.
561
00:26:14,091 --> 00:26:16,525
We have witnesses to
leila merton's neglect,
562
00:26:16,593 --> 00:26:17,994
a recording of her
yelling at the baby...
563
00:26:18,062 --> 00:26:19,495
You know I wouldn't prosecute a case
564
00:26:19,563 --> 00:26:21,163
based purely on medical evidence.
565
00:26:21,230 --> 00:26:22,630
And you know expert witnesses
566
00:26:22,698 --> 00:26:24,499
don't get immunity anymore.
567
00:26:24,567 --> 00:26:27,169
Because of unsafe convictions
based on tenuous evidence.
568
00:26:27,236 --> 00:26:30,105
I am not about to put
my career on the line.
569
00:26:30,173 --> 00:26:33,141
Are you 100% certain
this baby was shaken?
570
00:26:33,209 --> 00:26:35,643
Yes. You know I am.
There's no other explanation.
571
00:26:35,711 --> 00:26:38,613
Then a jury needs to hear that.
572
00:26:41,049 --> 00:26:45,186
Violently shaking a baby can cause
the brain to move within the skull,
573
00:26:45,253 --> 00:26:47,321
resulting in cerebral contusions
574
00:26:47,389 --> 00:26:49,524
or tearing of the blood vessels.
575
00:26:49,592 --> 00:26:51,459
The most common finding
in these babies
576
00:26:51,527 --> 00:26:54,260
is a triad of injuries, brain disease,
577
00:26:54,328 --> 00:26:57,163
and bleeding behind the
brain and behind the eyes.
578
00:26:57,231 --> 00:26:59,766
And did you find this
bleeding in Alex Raines?
579
00:26:59,834 --> 00:27:02,202
Yes, and it was severe.
580
00:27:02,269 --> 00:27:05,038
So in your opinion, was
baby Alex shaken to death?
581
00:27:05,106 --> 00:27:08,274
Well, unless he was
involved in a car crash,
582
00:27:08,342 --> 00:27:10,710
I can't think of any other
likely explanation.
583
00:27:10,777 --> 00:27:12,812
Thank you.
No further questions.
584
00:27:15,883 --> 00:27:20,285
Did you find any bruising on
the baby's arms or rib cage?
585
00:27:20,353 --> 00:27:22,522
No.
Any rib fractures?
586
00:27:22,589 --> 00:27:24,456
No, but... any traction
changes in the long bones,
587
00:27:24,525 --> 00:27:26,257
damage to the neck or spine?
588
00:27:26,325 --> 00:27:27,726
No.
589
00:27:27,793 --> 00:27:30,629
So out of seven expected findings
590
00:27:30,696 --> 00:27:33,798
in a case of shaken baby syndrome,
591
00:27:33,866 --> 00:27:35,400
you found only three.
592
00:27:35,467 --> 00:27:37,869
I found the three most common.
593
00:27:37,937 --> 00:27:41,639
And is this triad of injuries
594
00:27:41,706 --> 00:27:45,208
ever found in any other
condition in babies?
595
00:27:45,276 --> 00:27:49,146
Yes, but I checked.
There was no birth trauma, no vaccine damage,
596
00:27:49,213 --> 00:27:51,048
there was no vitamin c deficiency,
597
00:27:51,115 --> 00:27:53,417
and he tested negative to ga-1.
598
00:27:53,484 --> 00:27:56,820
Aren't you missing one other condition?
I don't think so.
599
00:27:56,888 --> 00:28:00,156
Is it not possible that
an accidental head injury
600
00:28:00,223 --> 00:28:03,693
can also cause the same pattern
of swelling and bleeding?
601
00:28:06,564 --> 00:28:08,631
Is that a difficult
question, ms radley?
602
00:28:08,699 --> 00:28:10,900
It's possible, yes.
603
00:28:10,968 --> 00:28:14,036
Is it not the case that
many pediatric experts
604
00:28:14,103 --> 00:28:16,605
now doubt the very existence
605
00:28:16,673 --> 00:28:18,941
of so-called shaken baby syndrome?
606
00:28:21,210 --> 00:28:23,278
Some do. I don't.
607
00:28:23,345 --> 00:28:26,314
I believe a significant number
of convictions have been quashed
608
00:28:26,382 --> 00:28:28,850
and caregivers released from prison.
609
00:28:28,918 --> 00:28:31,118
It's not my area of expertise,
610
00:28:31,186 --> 00:28:32,653
so I can't possibly comment.
611
00:28:32,721 --> 00:28:34,589
No, that's right.
612
00:28:34,656 --> 00:28:38,358
You aren't an expert in
head injuries at all, are you?
613
00:28:38,426 --> 00:28:42,964
I'm an expert in pediatric forensic
pathology, and I did the postmortem.
614
00:28:45,067 --> 00:28:47,100
One final question.
615
00:28:47,167 --> 00:28:51,170
When you did the postmortem,
did you examine the dura?
616
00:28:51,238 --> 00:28:53,974
The outermost layer of the meninges
617
00:28:54,041 --> 00:28:57,343
which surrounds the
brain and spinal cord.
618
00:28:57,411 --> 00:28:59,613
There was no reason to.
Really?
619
00:28:59,680 --> 00:29:01,780
You found bleeding in the brain
620
00:29:01,848 --> 00:29:04,282
and you didn't examine the dura
621
00:29:04,350 --> 00:29:06,551
to see if a clot from
a previous injury
622
00:29:06,620 --> 00:29:07,987
might have left an imprint?
623
00:29:10,423 --> 00:29:14,259
To the best of my knowledge, there
is no history of previous injuries.
624
00:29:14,327 --> 00:29:16,729
To the best of your knowledge.
625
00:29:18,130 --> 00:29:19,897
No further questions.
626
00:29:19,965 --> 00:29:21,398
James: With Lloyd exonerated,
627
00:29:21,466 --> 00:29:23,701
Helena was bound to have a
go at the medical evidence.
628
00:29:23,769 --> 00:29:25,202
She has to create reasonable doubt.
629
00:29:25,270 --> 00:29:26,671
She did a good job of it.
630
00:29:26,739 --> 00:29:28,539
According to Alex Raines'
medical records,
631
00:29:28,607 --> 00:29:31,308
there was no accidental head injury.
632
00:29:31,376 --> 00:29:34,676
The jury will see she's just
trying to muddy the waters.
633
00:29:36,487 --> 00:29:38,755
You had access to the Raines' house?
634
00:29:38,823 --> 00:29:40,590
Yes, I'm in the office most days.
635
00:29:40,658 --> 00:29:42,659
It's in the house.
636
00:29:42,727 --> 00:29:46,262
So you saw how the defendant
interacted with baby Alex
637
00:29:46,331 --> 00:29:47,863
when mr and mrs Raines
weren't at home?
638
00:29:47,931 --> 00:29:51,801
She didn't. She was usually on
the sofa checking her email.
639
00:29:51,868 --> 00:29:53,436
And where was the baby?
640
00:29:53,503 --> 00:29:56,271
Either in his cot upstairs,
or in his playpen.
641
00:29:56,340 --> 00:29:58,774
More often than not, he was crying.
642
00:30:00,711 --> 00:30:02,945
A few days before Alex died,
643
00:30:03,012 --> 00:30:04,612
he was very distressed.
644
00:30:04,680 --> 00:30:07,982
He'd been sick.
It was all over his clothes.
645
00:30:08,050 --> 00:30:09,984
And the defendant didn't go to him?
646
00:30:10,052 --> 00:30:12,487
I...Called to her,
647
00:30:12,555 --> 00:30:15,824
but she didn't hear me.
She had her headphones on.
648
00:30:15,891 --> 00:30:18,360
Presumably she couldn'tear
the baby crying.
649
00:30:18,427 --> 00:30:22,596
No. I went downstairs and told her Alex
was unwell, that he needed changing.
650
00:30:22,664 --> 00:30:25,165
Did she go to him then?
651
00:30:25,233 --> 00:30:28,635
No, she just put her headphones back
on and went back to her laptop.
652
00:30:28,703 --> 00:30:32,606
Did you ever witness the defendant
being violent toward the child?
653
00:30:32,674 --> 00:30:34,408
A couple of weeks before Alex died
654
00:30:34,476 --> 00:30:36,642
I was in the kitchen
making a cup of tea,
655
00:30:36,710 --> 00:30:38,811
and Alex was in his highchair.
656
00:30:38,879 --> 00:30:40,546
He'd thrown his bowl,
and there was food
657
00:30:40,614 --> 00:30:42,482
all over the walls and floor.
658
00:30:42,549 --> 00:30:43,783
What did leila do?
659
00:30:43,851 --> 00:30:45,585
She shouted at him,
660
00:30:45,652 --> 00:30:46,919
then she grabbed him out of the chair
661
00:30:46,987 --> 00:30:48,954
and shoved him into the playpen.
662
00:30:49,022 --> 00:30:51,690
That girl didn't give a
damn about that baby!
663
00:30:51,758 --> 00:30:53,124
Judge: The jury will disregard
664
00:30:53,192 --> 00:30:56,194
the witness's last comments.
665
00:30:56,262 --> 00:30:59,030
Suzanne: We thought she
genuinely cared for Alex.
666
00:30:59,098 --> 00:31:00,999
We trusteder.
667
00:31:01,066 --> 00:31:05,637
Did you ever observe her
being rough with Alex?
668
00:31:05,705 --> 00:31:09,374
No. But she told the police
that she left him to cry,
669
00:31:09,441 --> 00:31:12,377
and she knew how strongly
I felt about that.
670
00:31:12,444 --> 00:31:14,445
Must have been very difficult for you
671
00:31:14,513 --> 00:31:16,514
toand over such a young child
672
00:31:16,581 --> 00:31:18,049
while you went out to work.
673
00:31:18,117 --> 00:31:20,818
Broke my heart.
Every day it broke my heart.
674
00:31:20,886 --> 00:31:22,987
Thank you.
675
00:31:27,325 --> 00:31:30,427
I'm sorry for your loss, mrs Raines.
676
00:31:30,494 --> 00:31:34,164
I appreciate how difficult it must
be for you to come here today.
677
00:31:34,232 --> 00:31:37,401
Were you and your husband in some
sort of financial difficulty?
678
00:31:37,468 --> 00:31:40,136
No.
But you returned to work
679
00:31:40,203 --> 00:31:42,004
when your baby was
just a few weeks old.
680
00:31:42,072 --> 00:31:44,706
Without my wages we had nothing left
681
00:31:44,774 --> 00:31:46,708
after the mortgage and
the bills were paid.
682
00:31:46,776 --> 00:31:49,345
It was a difficult year.
The market's picking up now.
683
00:31:49,413 --> 00:31:52,681
So you can pay for all
the little extras. Yes.
684
00:31:52,749 --> 00:31:56,217
Holidays, nice car, wine club.
Yes.
685
00:31:56,285 --> 00:32:00,788
Without those luxuries, you could have
stayed home and looked after your baby.
686
00:32:00,856 --> 00:32:03,724
I need my job.
More than your child?
687
00:32:03,792 --> 00:32:07,128
Whether or not mrs Raines
chooses to go out and work
688
00:32:07,196 --> 00:32:09,664
has no bearing
whatsoever on this case.
689
00:32:09,731 --> 00:32:12,032
I'm simply trying to paint
a picture for the jury
690
00:32:12,100 --> 00:32:14,234
of life in the Raines home.
691
00:32:14,302 --> 00:32:17,504
Let's keep that picture in a
simple frame, ms marsden.
692
00:32:17,572 --> 00:32:19,440
We don't need to gild it, now, do we?
693
00:32:19,507 --> 00:32:22,376
Were you aware when you
hired leila merton
694
00:32:22,444 --> 00:32:24,979
that she'd recently been
fired by another family?
695
00:32:25,046 --> 00:32:27,047
No. I had no idea.
696
00:32:27,115 --> 00:32:29,882
We trusted the agency
to be open with us.
697
00:32:29,950 --> 00:32:32,051
How much research did you do
698
00:32:32,119 --> 00:32:35,821
on this agency that
supplies untrained nannies?
699
00:32:37,624 --> 00:32:39,725
Would you like me to
rephrase the question?
700
00:32:39,793 --> 00:32:41,461
My neighbor's sister uses them.
701
00:32:41,528 --> 00:32:43,062
I see.
And what's her name?
702
00:32:43,130 --> 00:32:45,330
My neighbor?
No, her sister.
703
00:32:47,868 --> 00:32:50,803
The court reporter needs to
take this down, mrs Raines.
704
00:32:52,506 --> 00:32:54,006
I don't know.
705
00:32:54,073 --> 00:32:56,609
Yet you trusted her judgment
706
00:32:56,676 --> 00:32:59,277
when it came to the
welfare of your child?
707
00:32:59,345 --> 00:33:01,312
Is this any of this actually
relevant to the case?!
708
00:33:01,380 --> 00:33:04,716
I think not.
Consider yourself warned,
709
00:33:04,783 --> 00:33:06,384
ms marsden.
710
00:33:06,451 --> 00:33:08,319
On the day your son died,
711
00:33:08,387 --> 00:33:11,689
you left the house at five A.M.
712
00:33:11,757 --> 00:33:14,425
And didn't return until your
husband calledou away from work
713
00:33:14,493 --> 00:33:16,593
at ten P.M.
is that correct?
714
00:33:16,661 --> 00:33:20,330
I had a late night viewing.
We're selling some apartments on the river.
715
00:33:20,398 --> 00:33:24,535
You were away from the
house for some 17 hours.
716
00:33:24,602 --> 00:33:26,503
Does your job often require you
717
00:33:26,571 --> 00:33:29,773
to work so late into the evenings?
Occasionally.
718
00:33:29,841 --> 00:33:32,475
So you were swanning around
some luxury penthouse
719
00:33:32,543 --> 00:33:34,644
while someone else was changing
720
00:33:34,711 --> 00:33:36,779
your baby's dirty nappies.
721
00:33:36,847 --> 00:33:39,549
I loved my baby.
Of course you did,
722
00:33:39,616 --> 00:33:42,184
you just didn't have any
time to spend with him.
723
00:33:42,252 --> 00:33:45,821
My lord, mrs Raines is not
the one on trial here.
724
00:33:45,889 --> 00:33:47,790
Ms marsden, you will
be held in contempt
725
00:33:47,858 --> 00:33:51,026
if you do not return to an
appropriate line of questioning.
726
00:33:51,094 --> 00:33:53,762
The jury will disregard
your last comments.
727
00:33:53,829 --> 00:33:59,401
One more question, mrs Raines.
728
00:33:59,469 --> 00:34:02,304
Bumps to the head, in the
month before his death?
729
00:34:02,372 --> 00:34:05,139
He has just started crawling.
Of course he had bumps.
730
00:34:05,207 --> 00:34:07,542
You show me a baby
that doesn't.
731
00:34:07,609 --> 00:34:11,045
Any particular incident come to mind?
732
00:34:13,615 --> 00:34:16,951
He fell off his changer when
Michael was reaching for a nappy.
733
00:34:17,018 --> 00:34:19,720
It was three weeks before he died.
734
00:34:19,788 --> 00:34:22,189
The gp said he was fine.
735
00:34:24,825 --> 00:34:26,893
No further questions.
736
00:34:30,698 --> 00:34:32,599
Alesha: That was quite a performance.
737
00:34:32,666 --> 00:34:35,935
Helena: The jury has a right to
know what sort of mum she is.
738
00:34:36,003 --> 00:34:38,437
A working one.
You made her look like rose west.
739
00:34:38,505 --> 00:34:41,407
Because I showed she put her
job before her own child?
740
00:34:41,475 --> 00:34:45,010
Because you played on misconceptions
held by half the jury.
741
00:34:45,078 --> 00:34:47,179
Come on, Helena, you're a working mum.
742
00:34:47,247 --> 00:34:48,647
You know how tough it can be.
743
00:34:48,715 --> 00:34:50,316
Do you think I'd be doing this
744
00:34:50,383 --> 00:34:52,884
if my ex hadn't buggered
off with his therapist?
745
00:34:52,952 --> 00:34:55,186
I think you'd still be up in court on
your zimmerframe if they'll let you.
746
00:34:59,225 --> 00:35:01,259
Madam foreperson,
747
00:35:01,327 --> 00:35:04,229
please answer my first
question either "yes" or "no".
748
00:35:04,296 --> 00:35:05,896
Have you reached a verdict on which
749
00:35:05,964 --> 00:35:08,733
at least ten of you have agreed?
No.
750
00:35:08,800 --> 00:35:10,934
Would any more time assist?
751
00:35:11,002 --> 00:35:12,836
I don't think so, no.
752
00:35:12,903 --> 00:35:17,241
I must declare this jury have
been unable to reach a verdict.
753
00:35:17,308 --> 00:35:19,075
So what the hell do we do now?
754
00:35:19,144 --> 00:35:20,677
The crown has seven days
to decide whether or not
755
00:35:20,745 --> 00:35:22,679
they will be retrying.
756
00:35:22,747 --> 00:35:25,248
The case will be listed for
mention a week on Monday.
757
00:35:28,985 --> 00:35:30,753
( James clears throat )
758
00:35:30,820 --> 00:35:34,423
We have to make sure the next jury
are certain of leila merton's guilt.
759
00:35:34,491 --> 00:35:36,825
You don't think a retrial will
be a waste of public money?
760
00:35:36,893 --> 00:35:38,927
She knew that baby wasn't well,
761
00:35:38,995 --> 00:35:40,863
but instead of taking care of him,
762
00:35:40,930 --> 00:35:43,898
she was more interested in making
homemade porn with her boyfriend.
763
00:35:43,966 --> 00:35:46,668
Well, she wasn't trained in childcare.
764
00:35:46,735 --> 00:35:49,137
If the Raines expected her
to do those sort of hours,
765
00:35:49,205 --> 00:35:50,838
they should have hired
a fully trained nanny.
766
00:35:50,906 --> 00:35:53,941
A trained nanny costs the
best part of 30 grand a year.
767
00:35:54,009 --> 00:35:56,278
They could never afford that.
768
00:35:56,345 --> 00:36:00,113
Suzanne said she took Alex
to the gp after a fall,
769
00:36:00,182 --> 00:36:02,283
but there's no mention of
it in the medical records.
770
00:36:04,653 --> 00:36:06,820
I thought she was an
over-anxious new mum.
771
00:36:06,888 --> 00:36:09,122
You know how many I get
in here every day?
772
00:36:09,191 --> 00:36:11,758
But there's no record of the
injury in Alex Raines' notes.
773
00:36:11,826 --> 00:36:13,293
Because there was no injury.
774
00:36:13,360 --> 00:36:16,362
I checked the baby's head...
No bump, not even a bruise.
775
00:36:16,430 --> 00:36:18,764
Is is possible that Alex could
have had an internainjury
776
00:36:18,832 --> 00:36:21,033
without any signs of an external one?
777
00:36:21,101 --> 00:36:23,203
I'm a gp, mr steel, not a specialist.
778
00:36:23,270 --> 00:36:25,037
That's something you'll
have to ask the pathologist
779
00:36:25,105 --> 00:36:26,673
who did the postmortem.
780
00:36:29,042 --> 00:36:30,509
I told you what I believed
781
00:36:30,577 --> 00:36:33,144
according to the
evidence I'd been given.
782
00:36:33,213 --> 00:36:35,847
You're the expert, Lucy.
You should have told me the full story.
783
00:36:35,915 --> 00:36:38,517
This accidental injury three
weeks before he died...
784
00:36:38,585 --> 00:36:42,153
The fall from the changer, which
I knew absolutely nothing about.
785
00:36:42,222 --> 00:36:44,356
I'm not interested in who's to blame.
786
00:36:44,424 --> 00:36:47,391
I just need to know if it
could have caused his death.
787
00:36:47,459 --> 00:36:49,227
There are cases
788
00:36:49,294 --> 00:36:52,062
where a baby has an
accidental bump to the head,
789
00:36:52,130 --> 00:36:53,764
shows no outward signs of damage,
790
00:36:53,832 --> 00:36:55,833
and then dies a few weeks later
791
00:36:55,900 --> 00:36:57,501
when the bleeding is triggered again.
792
00:36:57,569 --> 00:36:59,036
It's rare, but it does happen.
793
00:36:59,104 --> 00:37:00,938
But something would need
to trigger the bleeding.
794
00:37:01,005 --> 00:37:02,539
Well, it wouldn't take much.
795
00:37:02,607 --> 00:37:04,541
If the baby's head hit a surface
with a small amount of force,
796
00:37:04,609 --> 00:37:06,443
the bleeding could start again.
797
00:37:06,510 --> 00:37:08,878
Are you seriously telling me his
death could have been accidental?
798
00:37:08,946 --> 00:37:12,815
Well, I'd need to reexamine the
brain in the skull to be sure.
799
00:37:12,883 --> 00:37:14,984
Exhume the body?
800
00:37:16,387 --> 00:37:18,854
It's your call, James, not mine.
801
00:37:18,921 --> 00:37:21,823
But to be certain? Yeah.
802
00:37:33,212 --> 00:37:35,480
Michael: No.
803
00:37:36,083 --> 00:37:37,517
Michael, you shouldn't have come.
804
00:37:37,585 --> 00:37:40,119
I had to see it for myself.
805
00:37:40,187 --> 00:37:42,988
Please, I'm begging you, don't do it.
806
00:37:43,056 --> 00:37:45,024
We have to know.
807
00:37:53,299 --> 00:37:55,034
Lucy called.
808
00:37:55,101 --> 00:37:57,603
There are signs of a healing
fracture in Alex's skull.
809
00:37:57,671 --> 00:37:59,037
How recent?
810
00:37:59,104 --> 00:38:01,138
The healing is consistent
with a bump to the head
811
00:38:01,206 --> 00:38:02,774
three weeks prior to death.
812
00:38:02,841 --> 00:38:05,109
A re-bleed could have been
triggered by another bump.
813
00:38:05,177 --> 00:38:08,079
Andrea said she saw leila being
heavy-handed with the baby.
814
00:38:08,146 --> 00:38:10,414
Maybe she bumped his head by accident.
815
00:38:12,952 --> 00:38:16,386
I was never rough with Alex, even
when I'd been up half the night.
816
00:38:16,454 --> 00:38:20,356
Andrea claims you were.
She's lying. I never hurt him.
817
00:38:20,424 --> 00:38:23,727
You didn't drop him accidentally?
No.
818
00:38:23,795 --> 00:38:25,596
Alesha: It happens.
819
00:38:25,663 --> 00:38:28,198
You're tired, the baby slips
out of your hands? No.
820
00:38:28,265 --> 00:38:29,866
You're certain?
I'd tell you.
821
00:38:29,934 --> 00:38:32,835
I don't want to spend the
rest of my life inside, do I?
822
00:38:32,903 --> 00:38:34,369
Interesting as this is, James,
823
00:38:34,437 --> 00:38:36,038
is there a point to it?
824
00:38:36,106 --> 00:38:38,340
We think Alex's death...
825
00:38:38,408 --> 00:38:40,576
May have been accidental.
826
00:38:40,644 --> 00:38:42,478
Oh.
827
00:38:42,545 --> 00:38:44,780
In which case I'll be
filing for damages
828
00:38:44,848 --> 00:38:48,182
for the time my client spent
in custody on remand.
829
00:38:48,250 --> 00:38:51,119
I don't want to make
money out of this.
830
00:38:51,186 --> 00:38:55,556
Lloyd died with the whole world
thinking he was a baby murderer.
831
00:38:56,959 --> 00:38:58,860
He was my life.
832
00:39:02,197 --> 00:39:04,397
We offered her a
get-out-of-jail-free card.
833
00:39:04,465 --> 00:39:06,900
All she had to say was she
accidentally bumped the baby's head.
834
00:39:06,968 --> 00:39:09,770
But Andrea was certain that she
saw leila being rough with Alex.
835
00:39:09,838 --> 00:39:11,238
Yet leila claims she wasn't.
836
00:39:11,305 --> 00:39:13,473
Well, one of them's lying.
The question is, which one?
837
00:39:13,541 --> 00:39:15,643
Let's talk to Andrea again.
838
00:39:15,710 --> 00:39:17,344
I put that couple
through an exhumation.
839
00:39:17,411 --> 00:39:19,512
We have to find out
how their baby died.
840
00:39:19,579 --> 00:39:20,379
Andrea: I'm not
saying she meant
841
00:39:20,447 --> 00:39:22,248
to hurt Alex;
842
00:39:22,315 --> 00:39:24,283
she was just so wrapped up
in that boyfriend of hers.
843
00:39:24,351 --> 00:39:26,185
When I was nineteen I'd
much rather have been
844
00:39:26,253 --> 00:39:28,054
writing love letters to Michael
845
00:39:28,122 --> 00:39:29,889
than spoon-feeding a baby.
846
00:39:29,957 --> 00:39:31,991
You were with Michael
when you were nineteen?
847
00:39:32,059 --> 00:39:33,826
Eighteen.
We met at university.
848
00:39:33,894 --> 00:39:35,694
Fresher's ball.
849
00:39:35,762 --> 00:39:37,029
You never wanted kids?
850
00:39:37,096 --> 00:39:39,698
Do I look like the maternal type?
851
00:39:39,766 --> 00:39:43,035
I wouldn't know one
end from the other.
852
00:39:43,102 --> 00:39:45,671
I have a meeting with a
supplier in an hour.
853
00:39:45,738 --> 00:39:50,208
Leila merton denies ever
being rough with the baby.
854
00:39:50,276 --> 00:39:51,909
I know what I saw.
855
00:39:51,977 --> 00:39:54,045
You're the only person that saw that.
856
00:39:54,112 --> 00:39:57,715
Even Suzanne never witnessed leila
be anything but gentle with Alex.
857
00:39:57,783 --> 00:40:00,617
Well, maybe it wasn't leila.
Maybe it was the boyfriend.
858
00:40:00,686 --> 00:40:01,585
Really?
859
00:40:01,653 --> 00:40:03,620
I don't mean on purpose.
860
00:40:06,291 --> 00:40:09,325
A few days...
Before Alex died,
861
00:40:09,393 --> 00:40:10,727
I passed his room.
862
00:40:10,795 --> 00:40:13,196
The door was open.
Leila's boyfriend was in there.
863
00:40:13,263 --> 00:40:14,497
And he was playing with the baby,
864
00:40:14,565 --> 00:40:17,067
flying him round the
room like an aeroplane.
865
00:40:17,134 --> 00:40:18,902
Alex was loving it, giggling.
866
00:40:18,969 --> 00:40:20,536
I didn't think of it at the time,
867
00:40:20,604 --> 00:40:24,573
but he was there, wasn't he?
The night that Alex died.
868
00:40:24,640 --> 00:40:26,575
Maybe he was playing the game.
869
00:40:26,642 --> 00:40:30,012
I mean, he could have hit Alex's
head against the wall or something
870
00:40:30,080 --> 00:40:31,413
without realising.
871
00:40:34,050 --> 00:40:36,451
Look, I really have to
get to this meeting.
872
00:40:36,519 --> 00:40:38,853
We'll let you know about the retrial.
873
00:40:43,592 --> 00:40:45,459
She's lying.
874
00:40:45,527 --> 00:40:46,627
Sounded possible.
875
00:40:46,695 --> 00:40:48,629
She just said she saw Lloyd
876
00:40:48,697 --> 00:40:50,765
a few days before Alex died.
877
00:40:50,833 --> 00:40:53,234
Lloyd Benson had been
on a tour of duty
878
00:40:53,301 --> 00:40:55,535
in Afghanistan for five months.
879
00:40:55,603 --> 00:40:57,704
He only got back the day Alex died.
880
00:40:57,772 --> 00:41:00,040
Leila had only been working
there three months.
881
00:41:00,108 --> 00:41:02,575
Lloyd had never been to
the Raines' house before.
882
00:41:02,643 --> 00:41:05,912
So if Andrea saw him in Alex's room,
883
00:41:05,980 --> 00:41:10,183
it must have been the night Alex died.
884
00:41:10,251 --> 00:41:12,384
Andrea made out that she
didn't want a baby,
885
00:41:12,452 --> 00:41:14,120
career comes first and all that.
886
00:41:14,187 --> 00:41:16,021
So? So, I talked to
Michael about it.
887
00:41:16,089 --> 00:41:18,157
Being in the Raines' house
the night Alex died
888
00:41:18,225 --> 00:41:19,759
wasn't the only thing she lied about.
889
00:41:19,826 --> 00:41:22,694
Andrea and Michael had seven
failed attempts at ivf.
890
00:41:22,763 --> 00:41:24,764
It nearly crippled them financially.
891
00:41:27,067 --> 00:41:28,767
It wasn't anyone's business.
892
00:41:28,834 --> 00:41:33,138
You lied about not wanting a baby.
893
00:41:33,205 --> 00:41:36,541
You share your personal failures
with all and sundry, do you?
894
00:41:36,609 --> 00:41:38,777
It must have been soul-destroying,
895
00:41:38,844 --> 00:41:42,514
going through all that and still not
having a baby at the end of it.
896
00:41:42,582 --> 00:41:44,715
What would you know?
897
00:41:47,619 --> 00:41:48,953
You want my advice?
898
00:41:49,021 --> 00:41:51,355
Have a baby before your eggs dry up.
899
00:41:53,058 --> 00:41:55,459
It can't have been easy,
watching the man you love
900
00:41:55,527 --> 00:41:58,163
have a baby with someone else.
901
00:41:58,230 --> 00:42:01,398
They didn't tell me.
Michael was too scared.
902
00:42:03,401 --> 00:42:06,636
I answered the door
when the cot arrived.
903
00:42:06,704 --> 00:42:08,205
That must have hurt.
904
00:42:08,273 --> 00:42:11,241
That's what happens
when you're infertile.
905
00:42:11,309 --> 00:42:13,277
People stop telling
you their happy news,
906
00:42:13,344 --> 00:42:16,445
stop inviting you to their
child-friendly parties,
907
00:42:16,513 --> 00:42:20,950
because you're not a member of
their exclusive little club.
908
00:42:21,018 --> 00:42:23,652
Andrea, leila's boyfriend
was in Afghanistan
909
00:42:23,720 --> 00:42:25,754
right up until the
day of Alex's death.
910
00:42:25,823 --> 00:42:28,191
I must have got the date wrong.
911
00:42:28,258 --> 00:42:30,293
We know for a fact he
only came here once.
912
00:42:30,360 --> 00:42:33,394
It w the night Alex died.
913
00:42:33,462 --> 00:42:35,964
You were here
914
00:42:36,032 --> 00:42:39,968
at Suzy and Michael's the
night Alex died, weren't you?
915
00:42:40,036 --> 00:42:42,603
I dropped off some files, then left.
That's it.
916
00:42:42,671 --> 00:42:45,073
So you've been lying all this time.
917
00:42:45,141 --> 00:42:47,842
You must have heard Alex crying.
918
00:42:47,909 --> 00:42:49,977
Yes, but I didn't go to him.
919
00:42:50,045 --> 00:42:51,678
Because you're not the maternal type.
920
00:42:51,746 --> 00:42:54,614
But that's not true, is it?
You wanted a baby more than anything.
921
00:42:54,682 --> 00:42:58,518
I didn't shake that baby!
I couldn't do that!
922
00:42:58,586 --> 00:43:01,188
No one shook him, Andrea.
923
00:43:01,256 --> 00:43:05,158
Alex's death was accidental.
924
00:43:05,226 --> 00:43:08,661
But he must have bumped
his head the day he died.
925
00:43:08,729 --> 00:43:12,065
On his cot, maybe?
926
00:43:13,901 --> 00:43:16,569
You went into his room, didn't you?
927
00:43:16,636 --> 00:43:18,838
They left him with a 19-year-old
kid, for God's sake!
928
00:43:18,906 --> 00:43:20,639
They never saw him!
929
00:43:20,707 --> 00:43:23,376
You wouldn't have done that, would you?
If he was yours.
930
00:43:23,443 --> 00:43:25,378
She didn't deserve him!
931
00:43:25,445 --> 00:43:29,114
She took my husband!
She took everything!
932
00:43:29,182 --> 00:43:30,716
You picked Alex up, didn't you?
933
00:43:30,784 --> 00:43:33,919
I just wanted to stop him crying.
934
00:43:33,987 --> 00:43:36,721
I held him.
I just held him.
935
00:43:36,789 --> 00:43:39,991
An innocent man was
accused of killing Alex.
936
00:43:40,058 --> 00:43:42,326
He was murdered in his prison cell.
937
00:43:46,131 --> 00:43:47,932
You have to tell us what happened.
938
00:43:50,603 --> 00:43:53,637
He stopped crying. He...
939
00:43:53,705 --> 00:43:55,572
He just wanted a cuddle.
940
00:43:59,076 --> 00:44:02,479
I looked into his eyes,
and I saw Michael.
941
00:44:02,547 --> 00:44:05,348
I saw the child I never had.
942
00:44:07,419 --> 00:44:10,219
It should have been my baby!
943
00:44:10,287 --> 00:44:11,854
It hurt so much
944
00:44:11,922 --> 00:44:15,190
to feel him in my arms and
know that I'll never...
945
00:44:17,528 --> 00:44:19,462
I'll never be a mum.
946
00:44:20,764 --> 00:44:23,599
What did you do, Andrea?
947
00:44:23,667 --> 00:44:27,068
I couldn't stand to hold him anymore.
948
00:44:30,640 --> 00:44:32,474
I just let go.
949
00:44:33,643 --> 00:44:36,511
I just...Let go.
950
00:45:04,404 --> 00:45:06,539
Loser buys?
You must have had your doubts.
951
00:45:06,607 --> 00:45:08,441
Everything said it was her.
952
00:45:08,509 --> 00:45:12,244
When's that stopped me defending
to the best of my ability?
953
00:45:12,312 --> 00:45:14,847
Do fancy another?
No, thanks.
954
00:45:14,914 --> 00:45:18,916
I should have been back an
hour ago for the baby-sitter.
955
00:45:18,984 --> 00:45:22,587
Want to share a cab?
No, I'm meeting Alesha.
956
00:45:22,654 --> 00:45:24,188
Watch out.
957
00:45:24,255 --> 00:45:27,458
Over 30, childless...
Tick-tock.
958
00:45:27,508 --> 00:45:32,058
Repair and Synchronization by
Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0